







A new identity for a new direction A new identity for a new direction
HoloChats: Matthew Schutte and Brian Robertson

Autopsy of a Failed Holacracy: Lessons in Justice, Equity, and Self-Management | Nonprofit Quarterly | Civic News. Empowering Nonprofits. Advancing Justice.
As many nonprofits look at the enormous potential benefits of building shared leadership in and around their organizations, they will surely stumble across the holacracy model, but does it offer a real path forward? In this article, a veteran of one change process intelligently critiques the model, providing guidance on what other organizations may wish to avoid. This is the first of a 3-part series on shared leadership we will run over the coming month.

Holacracy Is Fundamentally Broken
Holacracy is a top-down, bureaucratic, big government framework. It is completely the opposite of what agile, scalable organizations need in the 21st century.


Beyond the Holacracy Hype
Most observers who have written about holacracy and other forms of self-management take extreme positions, either celebrating these “bossless,” “flat” work environments for fostering flexibility and engagement or denouncing them as naive experiments that ignore how things really get done. To gain a more accurate, balanced perspective, the authors—drawing on examples from Zappos, Morning Star, and other companies—examine why these structures have evolved and how they operate, both in the trenches and at the level of enterprise strategy and policy. Self-organization models typically share three characteristics: Teams are the structure. Within them, individual “roles” are collectively defined and assigned to accomplish the work. Teams design and govern themselves, while nested within a larger structure. Leadership is contextual. It’s distributed among roles, not individuals, and responsibilities shift according to fit and as the work changes. Adopting self-management wholesale—using it to determine what should be done, who should do it, and how people will be rewarded across an entire enterprise—is hard, uncertain work, and the authors argue that in many environments it won’t pay off. But their research and experience also suggest that elements of self-organization can be valuable tools for companies of all kinds, and they look at circumstances where it makes more sense to blend the new approaches with traditional models.

Holacracy: a red herring in the quest for leadership
Does Holacracy liberate employees from the shackles of traditional management structures so they can perform like entrepreneurial leaders? Well, for me the answer’s a definite no. It’s a paradox that for Holacracy to succeed employees need a leadership mindset. But if they have that mindset in the first place they don’t actually need Holacracy. Let’s […]

Holacracy and 3 of the Other Craziest Management Practices Around | Fortune
These companies pride themselves on managing a little differently that most.

Taking Holacracy governance to the next level - Loomio
Explore how Holacracy's integrative decision-making process can help teams develop proposals together.



Holacracy, Zappos and Employment Law (LMFTFY)
Holacracy is a non-hierarchical management philosophy that is getting a lot of attention these days. As readers might know, Zappos recently adopted this ideology, famously eliminating bosses and j…
An Introduction to Self-Organization - Interaction Institute for Social Change
“The ideas of self-organization are very important to understand the autonomy, the authenticity and basic humanity of people.” -Fritjof Capra One principle of “thinking like a network” that I like to highlight is the notion of moving from permission and perfection (looking for the one right answer) to self-organization and emergence. Self-organization is a defining... Read More
Holding the Roots: Resourcing the Infrastructure Behind Movements - Interaction Institute for Social Change
There’s a quiet revolution underway. You can see it in church gatherings and small-town meetings, on Zoom calls between elders and young organizers, in community art projects, healing circles, and protest planning sessions. Across the country, IISC has had the deep honor of supporting and witnessing this movement: the call for food justice in Mississippi,... Read More

Hospicing Modernity
The book “Hospicing Modernity: Facing Humanity’s Wrongs and the Implications for Social Activism” was published in September 2021. If you are in Canada, you can purchase the book …

