







Article: Breeding, Marshall. Library Systems Report 2026: Innovation under constraint: how libraries and vendors navigate austerity and AI disruption. Uncertainties in funding and disruptions driven by AI technologies set the stage for a difficult year in the library technology industry. This phase of austerity presents significant challenges for libraries and the vendor industry. Some vendors will ride out the storm, waiting for more favorable conditions. Others will invest in developing new offerings or enhancing existing products that help libraries navigate these challenges. More than ever, libraries demand technologies to enable efficient operations while amplifying their impact on their communities.
Fighting for the Future of Libraries (With Jennie Rose Halperin)
Censorship, AI, and the role of librarians in a country with crumbling public institutions.
From instrument to institution: generative AI and the epistemic dispossession of the academic library
Purpose. This paper analyses the emergence of generative artificial intelligence (AI) not as a further tool in the automation of search but as an epistemic institution that produces, validates and distributes knowledge. It examines the structural mechanisms through which this transition marginalises academic libraries, displacing them from the epistemic functions of synthesis, evaluation and curation they have historically performed. Against the assumption that marginalisation is a technological inevitability, the paper argues that it is conditional and articulates the institutional conditions under which academic libraries can recover epistemic agency and reposition themselves as active participants in the knowledge infrastructure of the AI era.Design/methodology/approach. The paper adopts a conceptual, abductive approach, employing the Tron film trilogy as an analytical model of epistemic infrastructure transition rather than as a cultural metaphor. It integrates Science and Technology Studies, the philosophy of technology and library and information science scholarship. The historical reconstruction proceeds inductively, deriving three phases of library infrastructure development from particular technologies, from card catalogues to commercial scholarly platforms. The diagnosis proceeds deductively, deriving specific mechanisms of marginalisation from the premise that generative AI internalises epistemic functions. The recovery programme then translates that diagnosis into the institutional conditions under which academic libraries can respond.Findings. Generative AI constitutes a qualitative break in the history of knowledge infrastructure, crossing from the category of retrieval tool to that of epistemic institution that organises the conditions under which knowledge is produced and validated. Three mechanisms drive library marginalisation: disintermediation of the institutional mediator, dependency on training infrastructures beyond library governance and the transfer of epistemic authority from accountable institutions to opaque algorithmic systems. Scenario analysis yields three possible futures, full marginalisation, coexistence and co-authorship of epistemic infrastructure. The third is not inevitable but contingent on libraries claiming roles in data stewardship, AI governance and critical AI literacy.Research limitations/implications. As a conceptual contribution, the paper develops an analytical framework rather than empirical findings; its three mechanisms and three scenarios are theoretically derived and await empirical testing. The evidence base draws substantially on Anglophone, predominantly US LIS scholarship, which may limit transferability to other national and institutional contexts. Future research should operationalise and empirically validate the proposed mechanisms of marginalisation, assess the conditions for epistemic recovery across diverse library settings and examine longitudinally whether libraries that invest in data stewardship, AI governance and critical AI literacy realise the co-authorship scenario the framework identifies.Practical implications. Academic libraries should pursue three mutually reinforcing strategies. First, they should reposition themselves as active participants in the governance of the data ecosystems on which AI systems are trained, extending research data management towards stewardship of training corpora. Second, they should secure inclusion in university AI governance structures, from which information professionals are frequently absent despite directly relevant competencies in information ethics, source evaluation and quality assurance. Third, they should reconceptualise critical AI literacy, the capacity to evaluate not only what AI produces but how, as a defining institutional mission rather than a supplementary digital skill.Social implications. If generative AI becomes the default mediator of scholarly knowledge, the consequences extend beyond libraries to the epistemic commons on which science, scholarship and democratic deliberation depend. Unaccountable, non-transparent knowledge production risks normalising narrow epistemic positions, eroding epistemic pluralism and widening inequalities in knowledge access already stratified by institutional wealth. Positioning academic libraries as public-interest guarantors of accountable curation, epistemic equity and critical AI literacy helps safeguard citizens' capacity to evaluate AI-generated knowledge, sustains diverse knowledge traditions and protects the reliability of the shared information environment on which informed public life increasingly rests.Originality/value. The paper offers a novel integrative framework that combines Science and Technology Studies, the epistemology of AI and library and information science scholarship. Its central contribution is to reframe library marginalisation not as a contingent service challenge to be met by incremental adaptation, but as a structural consequence of AI's emergence as an epistemic institution. Methodologically, it advances the use of the Tron trilogy as an analytical model rather than an illustrative metaphor. It provides one of the first systematic articulations of academic libraries as potential co-architects, rather than residual beneficiaries, of the knowledge infrastructure of the AI era.

Feeding the Beast: Superintelligence, Corporate Capitalism and the End of Humanity
As part of the Digital Library's transition to Open Access, new features for researchers are available in the Premium Edition. Click here to learn more.

The Due Process Deficit: Auditing AI Governance in U.S. Higher Education
As part of the Digital Library's transition to Open Access, new features for researchers are available in the Premium Edition. Click here to learn more.

For The People
We all love libraries, and we all love reading - but that’s not enough. It’s essential that more leftists become involved in their local libraries. We’re being out-organized by a right-wing movement that’s focused on taking over public institutions to privatize & weaken them.

Why AI Will Not End Scholarly Publishing (and the Publish-or-Perish Institution)
The machine may not be consuming itself. It may be acquiring a much more efficient engine.

AI demand triggers massive PCB shortage for PC makers as order books full until 2030 — lead times stretch to 30 months as material costs surge 12x
The AI craze is now coming for our PCBs.

Why AI Companies Are Buying—And Then Destroying—Old Books
We've long joked about delaying bedtime in order to read the entire internet, but the prospect of actually doing so doesn't sound as appealing as it used to. An ever-growing proportion of text online, we may sense, hasn't been written by humans, but generated by artificial intelligence.

New Studies Confirm Today’s Academic Publishing System Is A Terrible Deal For Society · Techdirt
Walled Culture has just written about the possibility that recent AI breakthroughs might accelerate a move to open access, at least in the field of mathematics. It would be particularly welcome against a backdrop of relatively slow progress in the open access world. That is not because the need for different business models that provide...
State of AI 2026 | The Industry-Defining Report
Explore how AI is shaping the digital economy in 2026, with 80+ pages of data on ad spend, app downloads, web behavior, user demographics, and so much more.

AI is becoming a shopping channel: report
And 34% of shoppers now use the tech

The Paradox of Reuse in 2026: A Case of Quasi-Enclosure, or "Subsidized Club Goods that Sort of Look Like Public Goods"
How we can understand, and react to, the complicated impacts of AI systems on online communities and knowledge commons

The Paradox of Reuse in 2026: A Case of Quasi-Enclosure, or "Subsidized Club Goods that Sort of Look Like Public Goods"
How we can understand, and react to, the complicated impacts of AI systems on online communities and knowledge commons

We Need A Library Economy
Why AI is exposing design’s craft crisis
AI didn’t create the craft crisis in design — it exposed the technical literacy gap that’s been eroding strategic influence for over a decade.

AI And The Ship of Theseus
Slopforks: what happens when a library gets rewritten with AI?
