







I agree something like this seems correct but the details are maddening, and there are no sure answers.- which axes of diversity matter?- what's the reference class? - where do we get the data? - what about reality vs. fiction?A THREAD https://t.co/azNmp9kOAY— Jonathan Stray (@jonathanstray) February 23, 2024
Science doesn’t explain tech’s diversity problem — history does
You can’t fix something by ignoring it

Re: Seven Theses Against Viewpoint Diversity | The Paper Pilot
The Paper Pilot's digital garden of thoughts on philosophy, politics, and sociology
The importance of diversity in meteorology, technology and AI
The technology sector has long been synonymous with innovation, but lags behind when it comes to diversity. Kirstine Dale, Met Office CAIO, explains why we need to get our house in order.

As diversity increases, people paradoxically perceive social groups as more similar
With globalization and immigration, societal contexts differ in sheer variety of resident social groups. Social diversity challenges individuals to think in new ways about new kinds of people and where their groups all stand, relative to each other. However, psychological science does not yet specify how human minds represent social diversity, in homogeneous or heterogenous contexts. Mental maps of the array of society’s groups should differ when individuals inhabit more and less diverse ecologies. Nonetheless, predictions disagree on how they should differ. Confirmation bias suggests more diversity means more stereotype dispersion: With increased exposure, perceivers’ mental maps might differentiate more among groups, so their stereotypes would spread out (disperse). In contrast, individuation suggests more diversity means less stereotype dispersion, as perceivers experience within-group variety and between-group overlap. Worldwide, nationwide, individual, and longitudinal datasets ( n = 12,011) revealed a diversity paradox: More diversity consistently meant less stereotype dispersion. Both contextual and perceived ethnic diversity correlate with decreased stereotype dispersion. Countries and US states with higher levels of ethnic diversity (e.g., South Africa and Hawaii, versus South Korea and Vermont), online individuals who perceive more ethnic diversity, and students who moved to more ethnically diverse colleges mentally represent ethnic groups as more similar to each other, on warmth and competence stereotypes. Homogeneity shows more-differentiated stereotypes; ironically, those with the least exposure have the most-distinct stereotypes. Diversity means less-differentiated stereotypes, as in the melting pot metaphor. Diversity and reduced dispersion also correlate positively with subjective wellbeing.

HOW SHOULD WE LIVE IN A DIVERSE SOCIETY?
This is a transcript of my talk at the Castrum Peregrini in Amsterdam on 2 May. (Apologies for the lack of links and references; I will sort them out in due course when I have more time.) ‘Can Eur…

“Diversity” and “inclusion” aren’t interchangeable. Here’s how to use them correctly
As an educator, I’ve always found it helpful to begin a lesson with a review of vocabulary. There’s nothing worse than looking out over a sea of blank faces during the middle of a lesson and finding out that there is confusion over foundational concepts. It is better to flag and address potential misunderstandings right away.

Dissecting the Google Employee’s Anti-Diversity Manifesto, Piece-by-Piece
Part 3: Facts claimed, facts maimed (more).

Diversity, equity and inclusion
I'm in favour of diversity, equity and inclusion in open source communities, and here's why I think it matters.

Why Racists Lose Wars - Strange Matters
Trump's military is slashing diversity. Jason Lyall's book proves ethnic chauvinism loses wars and collapses states

Google releases first diversity report since the infamous anti-diversity memo | TechCrunch
Google has released its first diversity report since the infamous James Damore memo and the fallout that resulted from it. Those are both long stories but

Dissecting the Google Employee’s Anti-Diversity Manifesto, Piece-by-Piece
Part 2: Facts claimed, facts maimed.

Seven Theses Against Viewpoint Diversity
Demands for “viewpoint diversity,” a pillar of the Right’s strategy to remake higher education, collide with the pursuit of truth.

The Illusion of Asymmetric Insight
The Misconception: You celebrate diversity and respect others’ points of view. The Truth: You are driven to create and form groups and then believe others are wrong just because they are oth…

Deep Adaptation opens up a necessary conversation about the breakdown of civilisation
Many scientists say that societal collapse is now a likely outcome. We must prepare for this possibility and not deny its plausibility.

What and Whose Knowledge? Measuring Epistemic Diversity in Large Language Models
Large language models (LLMs) are increasingly used as primary knowledge sources, yet their epistemic diversity - defined as the diversity of real-world claims in their outputs - has never been measured. Low epistemic diversity would pose a risk of knowledge collapse as homogeneous LLMs mediate a shrinking in the range of accessible information over time. The dominant paradigm is that overall LLM diversity is low, but this is always with respect to a single point in time, with no reference baseline or consideration for variation across countries. We address this gap in knowledge by performing the first systematic study of epistemic diversity in LLMs across time and cultural context, testing 27 LLMs on 155 topics covering 12 countries, resulting in 1.7M responses and 70M individual claims. We find that epistemic diversity has increased substantially over the past three years, a positive counter to recent diversity pessimism. However, despite progress, we find that every system is less diverse than a search baseline. This gap is not uniform: RAG can improve diversity, while large models are counterintuitively less diverse than smaller ones. Moreover, LLM parametric knowledge systematically reflects English over local-language knowledge for country specific topics. Together, these results demonstrate that while progress on epistemic diversity is tangible, it is insufficient and unevenly distributed.


Temperature Zero for Culture: Why Everything Is Starting to Look the Same